mcgurrin posted a comment on Wednesday 3rd February 2010 12:22am

I like it, why has it not been updated in so long?

Zpenergy posted a comment on Wednesday 13th January 2010 5:48am

Great Xover. I have never read the other book that this story is crossed with, but you kept my attention anyway. Keep up the hard work!

matt2256 posted a comment on Tuesday 5th January 2010 7:27am

This has been a unique and interesting story to this point. I am dismayed to see it left on hiatus. I hope to see more of your work in the near future and thank you for the work to date.

Koalasco posted a comment on Monday 28th December 2009 6:54pm

I am not joking when I say that this is, most definitely, the most original, probably the most well-written, story I have ever read, and this includes non-fanfiction. And believe me, I'm an avid reader.

This story ranks immediately in my Top Ten of All Time. Seriously. Maybe even the top five.

It's such a pity that this is discontinued... or at least, on a long hiatus. Are you planning on finishing this? It would be highly interesting.

I appreciate the wonderful writing, the fantastic characters (even though they aren't yours, you write them very well), the great plot...

Please update soon... I'll review!

Yours,

Koalasco

Nargus posted a comment on Friday 25th December 2009 5:08am

Mmm...a change from most other Harry Potter fic, certainly :p

FailGate posted a comment on Thursday 24th December 2009 9:59am

For such an advanced civilisation, Harry is very uncouth. Isnt his language supposed to be peacefull? Sma may have set an example, but the same is true for her. For such a harmonic language, they like their swearing :)
Good chapter, they really have no idea what they are getting into, do they :/

FailGate posted a comment on Thursday 24th December 2009 2:01am

I have been enjoying your story, but find myself in the odd position of feeling sympathy for Dumbledore (which is extremely rare for me). Reading his interactions with Sma, I really wanted him to silencio her, or something of the like. Im just finding Harry and Sma's attitudes annoying at the moment. I realise the reasons behind it, but still I am looking forward to it toning down a tad (hopefully).
Besides from that, your story is very well written, and I believe I will check out your other works if they are up to this standard.
Merry Christmas/Holidays/Whatever.

flynhghr posted a comment on Wednesday 2nd December 2009 7:24pm

Please continue this, it's simply too much fun to leave idle! I'd imagine you had a bit of outcry about the sorting, but I think it's only logical with the upbringing. Surprising the hat didn't reference the differences in sexual experience when compared to the typical 11 year old. I really hope you keep this going, it's a wonderful piece of work.

flynhghr posted a comment on Wednesday 2nd December 2009 5:34pm

I don't care how funny something is, I rarely laugh out loud, but Minerva slipping an oath like "Merlin's bollocks!" had me rolling! I hope you work on this story often, it's a piece of work. I've never heard of the whole Culture world, and typically dislike crossovers, but yours is done exceptionally well. It's inspiring me to look up the Culture stories because they sound quite interesting, allthough I doubt they will hold a candle to your work so far.

sidiousclone@gmail.com posted a comment on Monday 30th November 2009 1:25am

sorry looks very good not that i have read any of the material outside of the harry potter series hoping for more in the near future

Finwitch posted a comment on Sunday 13th September 2009 3:22pm

Interesting. I shall await you to continue this fic.

Alrissa posted a comment on Friday 17th July 2009 1:23am

Ran into the story agan, love the last chapter.

Missed, initially the part where the hat is speaking Marain and thought dirty laundry was being aired. But that's just my reading style.

Oh, And i love seeing both the culture and wizards being thrown off the loop. Good one.

ionicwake posted a comment on Friday 29th May 2009 4:54pm

damn it i love this fic .
to bad there hasn't been an update in ......sorry ranting !

noylj posted a comment on Thursday 7th May 2009 12:56am

I sure wish that Ruskbyte would come back and finish his great stories.

Kathryn Berry posted a comment on Wednesday 22nd April 2009 10:01am

Are you going to continue this one? I find it fascinating.

Banner posted a comment on Tuesday 21st April 2009 9:13am

I just reread this last chapter, and it's even better the second time. I caught a great deal more detail on the reread. This story is cheerfully blowing canon out of the water, and it's wonderful fun to watch.
It'll be interesting to see Harry's and Culture's reaction to Thestrals and dragons, which disobey ordinary laws of physics.

Lerris Smith posted a comment on Monday 20th April 2009 10:18pm

Amusing so far. With this kind of story I can't see the default of Voldemort being the primary plot. Certainly they posses the technology to blow him and his followers up on a daily basis, if needed.

Still, I'm curious where your going to take this..

nublar posted a comment on Friday 10th April 2009 5:19pm

Funny and very unique story. I'm looking forward to more. Thanks for the great read.

rede30325 posted a comment on Sunday 5th April 2009 4:10pm

More please.

Holly posted a comment on Monday 30th March 2009 6:59pm

I just found this story and I love it! Great job so far. Keep up the good work and update soon when you can!